I wrote the following for my works intranet forum. I figured it would serve decently here as well
Having had an opportunity to play with both Windows 8 and Office 2013, I figured I would create a topic here to allow people to see some comments about them.
When you first login to Windows 8, you are presented with a start screen that looks like the Windows Phone, a full screened tiled view that has various tiles to launch apps, software, view news, etc. One of those tiles is "Desktop"
Once you are at the Desktop, it will look similar to Windows 7, but with a couple of major caveates.
1) No Start button. There are various third party start button applications, including a decent (if a bit ugly) one that is distributed via Ninite.com. This fails in my opinion in a business environment where change can be difficult for some people to deal with.
2) It's hip to be square. There are no rounded corners and curves in Windows 8. It is designed for full screen on a tablet not on monitors, so the asthetic is that everything be full screen. This fails in my opinion in a business environment, where you are more likely to have large monitors and multiples.
Because Microsoft is turning your desktop into a glorified handset, they are pushing "Apps" Apps are a different paradism than software in how you purchase, maintain, how much they cost, etc etc. But the big thing is it seems that apps are updated through the MS App Store, not through Microsoft Update which still handles the Operating System, and core software from Microsoft. Again a big fail for business in my opinion.
Anti-virus is built in to Windows 8 by default. This is something they should have done 15 years ago, but now it is actually not a great thing for businesses because it conflicts with managed anti-virus. Specifically, we have no way to have an integrated control panel where we can view the anti-virus status of all the machines under our care with it. We need to use third party AV, and that can't be installed until Windows Defender is disabled.
The good: Multiple windows are back, so you can easily put one spreadsheet on one monitor and a different on the other and work efficiently.
Visually I think Office 2013 is awful. It has inherited the squareness of Windows 8, it also has a terrible color scheme. These two things added together get rid of all the visual queues I used to tell the end of one window and start of another. Some of this may be the fact that I am color blind, but there is a decent populace of color blind people.
How emails are visually identified as unread changes, and again I find it less visual obvious than earlier versions.
I guess those are my initial comments, feel free to chime in and disagree with me, tell me how smart I am, etc etc.